The message in 2010/2011 was “The future is MOBILE”. In 2012, the present is mobile and yes, numerous case studies and statistics later, most brands have cottoned onto the concept that a good mobile strategy should compliment your web strategy, NOT be an afterthought (and it most definitely IS NOT a smaller version of the web that is available on your phone).
With this finally being the message, some brands are finally getting it right and realizing that the mobile user experience (UX) is really a specialized field that needs the assistance from mobile professionals as it is a different mindset to that of a web user in that as much as its about content, context is equally important. Also something most key, is that the mobile user is most likely to be someone who is mobile and who needs to access their information on the go, which means ‘ease of use’ is also of vital importance.
Having been fortunate enough to have grown up and evolved my career in this exciting mobile space over the past few years, and also being an absolutely lover of shopping, and travel, I am always interested to see who is getting it right and to see what other big brands are doing. So naturally, when I recently read that the luxurious hotel chain Four Seasons, spent $18 million USD on their new mobile friendly site, I was extremely interested see what new learnings their latest masterpiece would bring to my mobile world as naturally with a hefty price and brand like the Four Seasons, one would have the perception they would be pulling out the ultimate mobile site.
When I entered their mobile site, I was a little surprised and thought I had entered the incorrect address. However, even a hard refresh did not help as this was indeed their mobile site:

The home page is simple and appears to have quick access to key functionality, however a lack of a search functionality seemed a bit odd but nevertheless, one would assume that the “Find a Destination” option would serve that purpose of me finding a hotel quite easily in Italy.
Choosing this option takes me to a ‘non-mobile’ friendly page which really is a smaller version of their website which displays quite poorly on my iphone. Two clicks later, I eventually get to the hotel I’m looking for in Florence Italy, which has lovely imagery, however all the core functionality i want to access is hidden deep down within the page.
As a spa girl (check out my pamperprincess.co.za blog :) ), I decide to look at their Spa facilities, and guess what, the site jumps yet again to another non-mobile friendly page (I’m sorry but wasn’t this mobile site meant to be the big win for Four Seasons in order to set the bar in mobile experiences?).
Anyway, my eyes are too tired and strained to read those pages on the phone, so all i want to do now is check out the prices of their suites, well two attempts later on this mobile site, i eventually gave up. Not only was it dead slow with images not loading properly, but the amount of clicks that were needed to find out the price of a hotel room was just about 10 too many (i actually lost count after 8).
So what is wrong with this entire mobile experience?
1) Lack of Key Mobile User Journeys
The simple and fundamentals of any website set and especially the mobile sites or applications are the core user journetys. Pretty pictures mean nothing if the site does not let me accomplish the goal I have in mind. The foundation of any user experience is the user journey and I’m afraid it’s the business analyst (NOT the interactive designer) that can help define these.
2) Lack of core functionality
Why is the search missing? Almost everyone goes to a site to find out information of some kind. With the exception of News-related sites on mobile phones (as people tend to be most interested in the most current news, which is always displayed anyway) , search tends to be a core functional task that is found on most m-commerce sites. Naturally if you have a search facility it has to work correctly (which quite a few sites don’t quite get right), so maybe that is why Four Seasons decided to leave it out.
3) Lack of navigation which result in a lack of ‘ease of use’
Again, a violation of basic mobile principles. To get to specific information that I wanted was an absolute nightmare, it literally felt like searching for a needle in a haystack.
4) The inconsistencies of jumping from mobilised pages to non-mobilsed pages
This was probably the worst experience of the mobile site. If one is going to mobilise, then mobilise properly or not at all.
5) Too many clicks to get to the (basic) information I wanted
I suppose this ties into point number 1 with the lack of clear defined user journeys.
In summary, for mobile web or apps, the user experience combined with the basics of core functionality coupled with best guessed intuition is everything. Thinking ahead, knowing your target user and always bearing in mind they are not in front of their computer, they are on their phone, most likely using one hand, multi tasking like crazy so the mobile experience has to be on the money and accurate, there really is no time for waffle.
The mobile experience that is developed for the mobile platform really is a specialised field that can only really be accomplished well by specialists in that area, taking a website and miniaturizing it, did not work 5 years ago and its certainly not going to work now. A business analyst and an interactive designer are two different roles. As beautiful as a site can be made by the creative, it takes a competent business analyst (also known as a product owner in todays modern world ) that specializes in mobile to help glue the pieces together to help bring out the core functionality that the interactive designer puts forward.
End of the day, one can beautify a rotten engine with Lamborghini or Ferrari body as long as you want, it still wont work and will be worthless that no amount of money can save (not even 18 million USD)